Ummmm...for some reason i have this hat and in the game I'm not wearing it.....=P

It usually happens when the item doesn't exist on the rankings.  

I have the same thing on my cleric in my signature, but it's really a talking witch hat

---

Yeah, me too.

I'm actually wearing the talking witch's hat,

but instead of showing up as itself or the rainbow hat,

I got this stupid feather hat thing.

---